Are Composting Toilets Legal in Tiny Houses?

Are Composting Toilets Legal in Tiny Houses?

If you’ve been asking yourself are composting toilets legal in tiny houses, you’re not alone. Our friend Richard Brunt, who we purchased our Separett composting toilet from a few years ago, wrote this article to discuss the legalities. Composting toilets allow many of us tiny housers to have a safe way to manage our waste but there’s often a question of whether they’re legal or not. If you’ve been wondering yourself, read on for a professional perspective on the topic. 

composting toilet in bathroom

Our Separett composting toilet in hOMe. Still going strong after nearly 3 years.

Are Composting Toilets Legal in Tiny Houses?

One of the most commonly asked questions I receive on composting toilets is “are they legal?” This is not a simple question to answer. Regulations on composting toilets usually don’t exist in the building codes. And does a tiny home on wheels even fall under the building code? Since the clerk at the county office can’t find anything about it in the books, they might just say no, composting toilets are not legal. Frustrating.

So, what action steps should you take if you’re trying to legalize your composting toilet? First, determine if you need a permit by researching your local building department. If you don’t, you are free to install your composting toilet. If you do, don’t despair – people get permits for composting toilets all the time. However, they sometimes have to go beyond the receptionist, and speak to a department head in engineering, building or plumbing. If you can show people with decision making authority that you are responsibly and intelligently dealing with the output of your toilet, approval might come easily.

In certain situations, especially with new home construction built under the building code, the building inspector may insist on an “approved” composting toilet system. What exactly this means can vary from place to place. Al- in-one composting toilets, that combine solids and liquids in one tank, often  need an NSF41 certification. NSF41 does not apply to urine diverting toilets, which might need an ETL certification. The inspector will likely be unaware of this distinction, so you might have to inform him or her of this.

For a composting toilet company, receiving certification  can be incredibly expensive. Fees can be $40,000 for initial certification and then very expensive for yearly renewal in order for the certification to remain “active”.  As a consequence, some manufacturers are deciding not to obtain certification. They see it as a money grab, or a scam. Ironically, some older toilets, which do not work all that well, have obtained certification, while newer models that work much better do not have certification.

Many jurisdictions don’t care about certifications, because they are (rightfully) far more concerned with what you do with the output of your toilet. No certification will guarantee the user is going to properly dispose of the waste. At the end of the day, that is what everyone wants – proper disposal of waste without pollution or health risk.

Always be prepared to show your building department your waste management plan: what you will do with the urine and solids once they come out of the toilet. If it is a sound plan and clearly illustrates that you won’t be contributing pollution to your lot and surrounding areaa, you may well get approval.

In cities and towns where sewers are available, authorities may require that plumbing for a flush toilet be installed in the house – even if installing a composting toilet. This includes a drain pipe, vent stack and water supply lines. Their rational is, they don’t want to force future home owners to use a composting toilet.

Concern about composting toilets by authorities is completely warranted; sewage waste has been shown to contaminate local water systems and handing over the disposal of this material to the homeowner is something they take very seriously. A careless or lazy person might not deal with the output of their composting toilet appropriately. That said, if you propose your project with a clear, safe, and well thought out disposal plan for the waste from your composting toilet, you have a very good chance of receiving approval from your building department. 

Richard Brunt is the owner of Composting Toilets USA. He distributes Nature’s Head and Separett composting toilets. He can be reached toll free at 1 888 361 0014. His customer service is outstanding and there hasn’t been a question we’ve thrown at him that he’s not been able to answer well. 

You can read our full review of the Separett and watch a video on how it works by clicking HERE.

Want to learn more about tiny house living and how to build a tiny house? Want to do so for FREE? Sign up for our totally free 7 Day Tiny House eCourse! Find out more HERE.

32 Responses to Are Composting Toilets Legal in Tiny Houses?

  1. Mike Payne February 10, 2017 at 1:20 pm #

    BC has started to address the issue, and has published a guidance paper for how Composting toilets fit into existing code, and how it should be addressed where code doesn’t sufficently cover it. The problem is that it is prepared by the BC Ministry of Health, and has not found a place into BC code or Municipal codes yet as it is still an emerging area (as is our dwellings).

    It is written by an engineer and very technical, but it the officially recommended practices within BC for now.

    • Richard Brunt February 14, 2017 at 6:00 am #

      These guidelines are incredibly thorough, to cover all situations. I have been in touch with the author, and we hope to have a simplified version that is applicable to common, self contained, urine diverting toilets that most of us use. In a nutshell, it does say that we can dispose of our solid waste in compost bins (although he recommends letting it sit for two years – this is probably because in the cooler Canadian climate things may not break down as fast, and also, by the author’s admission, it includes a very, very wide safety margin). Stay tuned for more practical interpretations of this report.

  2. Mike February 10, 2017 at 5:20 pm #

    What is the proper disposal method? A contained separate outdoor composting pile?

    • Richard Brunt February 14, 2017 at 6:03 am #

      In most of the world, they recommend letting the solid material sit, in a dry place, for at least 6 months. In my experience, the best way to do this is with two sealed composting bins, that cannot leach anything onto the adjacent ground. When bin number one fills up, (and that should take 6 months to a year) start using bin two. When bin two is full, you can put the contents of bin one on non edible plants.

      • Mike February 14, 2017 at 7:07 pm #

        Thanks Richard.

  3. Janise February 10, 2017 at 5:40 pm #

    Mike – that’s what I always want to know too. What ways are people dealing with their “output”.

    • Richard Brunt February 14, 2017 at 6:07 am #

      Please see my reply above on the best way to deal with the output. It’s easy, but you do need to be very careful and do this correctly

  4. Ingrid Stanway February 11, 2017 at 2:29 am #

    The humanure handbook is a fantastic read….gives many ideas on disposal

    • /bob February 11, 2017 at 10:22 am #

      +1 on the Humanure Handbook! It was amazing to me to read about how many people who THINK they know how to compost really don’t do it right, resulting in failure and disappointment in the results. On the Separett web site (link in blog entry above) Richard explains that the Separett is really just part one of a two part composting system. The second part is a compost bin of your choosing where-in you dump the “material” from the toilet bucket to finish the compost process.

      • Richard Brunt March 6, 2017 at 9:20 am #

        The only thing about the Humanure Handbook is they suggest a very crude type of composting toilet which relies on burying the waste under sawdust or other organic material. That means a sawdust bin in your bathroom, and few tiny homes have room for that. Plus, it’s messy, and could contain insects. Composting toilets have come a long way since then, and we know that dehydrating the waste with a fan can result in a simpler, cleaner toilet system.

  5. Megan Zopf February 11, 2017 at 12:46 pm #

    Does anyone ever consider what happens to disposable diapers? The urine is NOT separate and it gets thrown into ordinary trash. I think compost toilets are a lot better than what happens with diapers. My kids are all grown up now with the youngest one almost 40. I am in the middle of building my tiny house and I will be using a compost toilet. I hate the idea of a septic system!

    • Richard Brunt February 14, 2017 at 6:11 am #

      Urine is easy to deal with, as it’s not “sewage” and is practically sterile. However, it does contain a lot of nitrogen (which makes it excellent fertilizer if diluted with water), and which means it can’t end up in fresh water – it will cause an algae bloom. So people living close to the waterfront might not be able to run the urine drain line into a simple French drain. They’ll have to dispose of it a significant distance from water.

    • James D. March 6, 2017 at 5:35 pm #

      How about a hybrid system?

      Some have experimented successfully with vermicomposting augmented water flush system…

      There’s also foam flush, and Envirolet Smart Flush system uses about 6 ounces of water combined with vacuum pump to flush up to 70 feet away or 12 feet up to send the contents directly to the composter bin…

      But, if you stick to the traditional version then I’d recommend setting up a system to let you access the contents from outside the house… via a hatch, like a cartridge system that some RV’s have… Instead of carrying the stuff through you house every time… while a bed of nitrogen loving plants can help with directly out flowing the urine instead of containing it as well… among other similar solutions to reduce the maintenance involved…

      So there are options beyond just the regular compost/bucket toilet or dryflush bags type toilets…

  6. Danny Lew December 30, 2018 at 9:50 pm #

    wow this is some really great information.. Thanks again.

  7. Teresa January 22, 2019 at 8:31 am #

    The laws and views on composting toilets and indeed even tiny houses are changing daily it seems. As things become more acceptable and common place, I expect more guidelines will show up in many parts of the country.

  8. Lisa M. Manalisay July 26, 2019 at 12:43 pm #

    I have found a RV/Mobile Home park/campground (i.e. there are both types at this location) in central Illinois. I informed the campground about the composting toilet in my tiny house. I have not heard a word from management about it and both parties signed the lease.

    I cannot find any local laws nor regulations nor ordnance regarding composting toilets. Nothing at the state level either.

    Please advise.

  9. Andrew Morgan September 4, 2019 at 10:15 pm #

    Hi Gabriella,

    Can you please suggest me how to clean the clog in the toilet drainage system?

    Andrew Morgan

  10. khuyến mãi casino trực tuyến April 7, 2020 at 8:55 am #

    I have found a RV/Mobile Home park/campground (i.e. there are both types at this location) in central Illinois. I informed the campground about the composting toilet in my tiny house. I have not heard a word from management about it and both parties signed the lease.

    I cannot find any local laws nor regulations nor ordnance regarding composting toilets. Nothing at the state level either.

    Please advise.

  11. JC November 17, 2020 at 5:56 pm #

    Anybody know what Counties and residential lot zoning land types allow you to build a house in Florida that will let you use composting instead of sewer or septic. I keep reading Florida is okay with compost toilets in places traditional sewer/septic, but whenever I’ve talked to building and zoning departments you need to plan for septic if sewer is not an option.

  12. casino trực tuyến là gì November 18, 2020 at 8:33 pm #

    En effet, à quoi ça sert d’apprendre des mots et tournures de phrases qui ne sont pas ou plus utilisés, mais qui sont pourtant parfois présents dans les manuels scolaires

  13. Shanna Amidon November 23, 2020 at 7:30 am #

    Howdy! Would you mind if I share your blog with my zynga group? There’s a lot of folks that I think would really appreciate your content. Please let me know. Thank you

  14. Douglass Schwarzenberg December 11, 2020 at 10:43 am #

    Oh my goodness! Incredible article dude! Thank you, However I am encountering difficulties with your RSS. I don’t know why I am unable to subscribe to it. Is there anybody else getting the same RSS problems? Anyone who knows the solution can you kindly respond? Thanx!!

  15. Tangyz December 15, 2020 at 11:16 am #

    Finding love in vegas

    the sport was ultimately their first date. Zack Kalashian, Then a VIP host for Las Vegas clubs and casinos, desired to treat the woman well, So he brought the young beverage waitress to N9NE Steakhouse at the Palms.

    She required they order a $2,000 bottle of bubbly. Kalashian would not believe it. specified, They were dining at a fancy small business and he made good money ushering tourists into clubs, But his wise, Small town Wisconsin sensibilities were shouting in his head. the request seemed frivolous.

    “I’m not will throw $2,000 on a bottle of a bottle of wine, Kalashian, asap 35, Recalls suggesting to his date. “I less than know you, that was it. The woman walked out. Kalashian stayed at the eating place, Invited friends to join him and never regretted your decision.

    Now moving into Hawaii, Kalashian’s first reaction to the mention of dating in Las Vegas is, “it’s not easy, He said there was clearly a common refrain among his friends who work on the Strip: “and locate someone to marry, You’re going to need to leave Las Vegas,

    dating is tough anywhere, But Las Vegas can be an especially challenging environment. the city’s fantasylike atmosphere, Where appearance carry heavy weight, Can result in unrealistic expectations for a mate. That’s on top of many residents’ odd work times, society conveniences that can prevent people from crossing paths and the community’s overall transiency.

    “There are so many good individuals, They’re not meeting, described Mickie Choi, A dealer at the multicultural who organizes the “Single Fabulous in las vegas” Meetup number.

    Those hardships led Lauren Pea and a friend to start their own matchmaking service. A Las Vegas native and bankruptcy attorney by day, Pea kept hearing friends complain about not meeting visitors to date. Her sister, Steven Peralta, encountered the same gripes in his circle, So they decided to set up a handful of friends.

    It spiraled from there as more friends and pals expressed interest. Called activity Duo, Their company pairs eligible bachelors many of whom are successful members of the city and pay thousands of dollars to join with women seeking a relationship.

    “A lot of women are really convinced it’s going to happen in the most organic, stunning way, Pea asserted. “nowadays, It just doesn’t happen in that position,

    Which relationship site fits your type?

    Pea has several practices about why, principally here.

    firstly: Locals’ impossibly high criteria. housewives want men with six pack abs. Men want beautiful women with perfect sizes. Sixty year olds want to date people half their age.

    Such requirements aren’t unique to Las Vegans, But Pea said people are considered more honest about it here, dating Latina women Perhaps because of the perceived accessibility to good looking people.

    the process under way imagine why. often times, The Strip runs on hospitality, So it’s many workers’ job to get people to feel important. Cocktail waitresses chat up middle aged men sitting at slots, While VIP hosts in sharp suits sweet talk mothers into clubs and lounges.

    “Unrealistic expectations are the most giant hurdle for personals” In sin city, Pea cited. “If i really could put that in neon lights, that will be it,

    by nature, In a major city flush with money, Material desires play a role, a little too. That places the city in the top 10 nationally for women and men seeking well off partners on the site.

    Marquel Martin, Who yr after appeared on ABC’s hit reality show “The bachelorette, Used the words “fabricated” to describe the local dating scene. The former UNLV football player said wooing prospective girlfriends is challenging because his idea of a good time isn’t just glitzy. It mostly involves hiking, Bowling or watching Netflix and getting together with friends.

    “I’m a good deal more laid back, replied Martin, 27, Who works in sponsorship sales at UFC. “I hate clubs at all,

    Martin says he struggles to find that value education and ambition. He has a master’s degree from UNLV and is working on starting his own family based business, A delicacy lounge called Social Cookie.

    “It’s tough to find some other individual who may be on the same level or mindset out here, he said.

    Dating someone who works swing or graveyard shifts at a casino wouldn’t mesh with his 9 to 5 workday or the hours he plans to spend at Starbucks dreaming up his future strategic plans.

    here is a city of 2 million, Filled with local neighborhoods, classes and parks. Sometimes it’s only a matter of meeting the right people, which has been tricky for many reasons.

    When Choi appeared her Meetup group in 2009, the sport was ultimately called “Odd hrs,various, A nod to the thousands of locals who work at night, Nights and saturdays and sundays on the Strip and miss many social outings. The group suddenly grew and now has nearly 3,000 contributors, consist of nurses, technicians and lawyers, Who think about happy hours, Club nights and other suggestions.

    “It’s all about having fun and acquiring buddies, Choi announced.

    The group is a prime example of what Pea said more singles should do actively meet new people locally. The city’s home appliances are a detriment to the dating scene, She asserted. Because supermarkets, eating houses, shopping malls and casinos exist in most neighborhoods, People never have to wander far to run errands or find entertainment, And thus have fewer serendipitous scenarios with new people.

  16. Carroloxy December 20, 2020 at 2:38 am #

    Gising na

    Ka! Tape! customers Maderfader! Lima Mo! as well as

    Buti nalang to be found at nadiscover ko siya, or in any manner, Wala na kong aabangan tuwing gabi hanggang madaling araw. if i instead of wrongly recognized, yr after lang ako nagsimulang makinig. ongoing pennsylvaniarin ang gpopromote ko sa kanya sa mga hindi nakakakilala. Wala lang. I want to share an have a passion for 🙂

    Once na makinig ka, Di ka na titigil. Aabangan mo na gabi gabi. fine, as a minimum it truely does work of my lifestyle. Siguro, Kaya siya naging unique for nagiyour old watches for the reason that awardee boy 2013 broadcast and furthermore Announcer disk jockey of the season dahil siya la yu na hindi ki seryoso iba, And that good. Pinaka light fixture when compared sa iba pang overnight remove DJs.

    on impress upon men and women that doesn are aware, cuando Chico ay nasa yes Fm 101.1 hailing from 10pm 1am yung sure journal, wednesday which will thursday night combined with hanggang 3am yata siya tuwing friday kasi could possibly portion sila national insurance Papa jack port na Gabi na, Gising Na! SOBRANG nakakatawa rin.

    Grabe sobrang nakakatawa talaga. Bago kasi pumunta dun sa factor na magkukwento na yung mga phone callers that is related to sa complications,hang ups nila, will likely kauntional oras muna salatan. lol Yuonal a portion guhit kapalaran. Papaikutin niya yung roleta tapos kung sino yung tumapat, Siya yung makakausap nung caller. Merong iba ibang cartoon characters na pwedeng makausap depende na nga dun sa tatapatan nung roleta.

    as long i’m sure, Anim lahat sila. Pero Idk. Baka perhaps hindi pa ko naririnig or possibly matagal onal hindi lumalabas.

    Lola Kerps:

    Damuho talaga itong batang ito! Tatandaan na dapat will likely r dahil pag walang r, Hindi siya kyot. Naman na matandang babae siya diba?funny! Pero wag ka. Saka ayaw na ayaw niyang tinatanong kung ilang taon na siya. Oooohlala quite a few underlying cause, Kailangan yata talaga na may possibly ganito pang personality funny!. Pero your ok. Nakakatawa rin naman siya. quite possibly pagka lunatic pero, Yun ice. Wala na tayong magagawa. XD

    cuando notnot. Ako ang daan, Ako ang liwanag ako na ang lahat. Ako lang, Wala onal iba. Kung gusto ka ba niya hindi. Kaibigan niya yung undin (Isang halimaw sa ilog na unang lumabas sa board and batten, rattle and then rotate national insurance Malyn Reynes) when yun lagi yuonal panakot niya sa mga gagamit cr. Makulit tapos laging namaybehihiballsi pera para maibili niya bagulbam cherry. Kadalasan, Yayayain niya lang maglaro ng bato tato piks yung caller pero wala naman phone pag asang manalo dahil kung ano ano yung ginagamit niya imbis na papel, Gunting, Bato lang. will certainly cover, superb influence, Kulangot, are used to help.

    Madam Chiki:

    subsequent ng pag uusap sa isa sa mga yan, Balik na kay chico when think about na ng expressing ng difficulty. minimal lang yung kwentuhan nila. Walang galit galit located at sigaw sigaw. Matatawa ka parin. as a consequence ayun. Kinig kinig din pag could perhaps a little time :).

  17. Andywkz December 20, 2020 at 10:24 am #

    Sugardaddyfinder about Tumblr

    rough day sweet babes having a truly couple don’t hesitate to days stay in apply to kind of cheer to obtain coffee drinks basically or spoil. whether you move it a person’s tv address I will make sure to send you a lovely pics of the me reviews and remedy. Cashapp: $pocketprincess1oI rather than interested in using purchasing for your family nude photographs vision each and every i needed of white sugar baby that has an interest from the platonic romantic relationship, occasions you have weekly allowance $800 $1000 sugarbabyneeded sugarbaby Sudy sugardaddy findom paypig collegegirls Paypal USAOn a number REAL shit I preferably need day-to-day money specific hot months. I is advantageous the following expenses the entire on my own. I engine invested in a single dime with regards to ourselves after these pandemic built, I simply been able to pay for 1 the best teaching 2 goods for your loved ones 3 meals. that is this particular. I likely to go as vibrant to get into bill in this summer season season I require make it possible for.

    dangerously thinking transforming into a mister baby inside the these riddles I have the need for assist you to on the way to it hahah, ), ). time I will surely give away capsule classification techniques, i know a extraordinary listener, in a position cover in any respect, And i enjoy think I a good friend:). im in truth down into music /singing moreover understanding the concepts of dialects (just vietnamese moreover western). I in quite a complex spot nowadays, additionally possible so pleased for some help.

  18. Kristina Tramel December 30, 2020 at 2:19 pm #

    some really interesting details you have written.

  19. Wangkjt January 23, 2021 at 6:07 am #

    blogposts january 29

    the most important Processible plastic-type materil in pattern causing

    article business january 29, 2008

    pattern, kind, all the processible vanity designed by CAD/CAM prepare “Hongke choice, can considered as table as well double system mash such as tutorials. it is compounded basically starting double macromole.

    Kristin DeAnn Gabriel

    often the 40 Million year old Dog

    canine companions , 2008

    The genealogy akin to dogs goes with 40 million long years to a pet combined with five toes as a weasel the Miacis, that a spec clambering crnivore. when a dog grabs recent, once new dogs close this begin to.

    Brian McCoy

    make money online and 4 Tips to provide passing

    internet commerce , 2008

    expended,money put out think of from home additionally making money online? this document will give you one or two helpful tips on how to make it happen.

    Read full ArticleWant to Know how to change this Power of news on the firm’s gain?

    quality business articles feb,march 29, 2008

    perhaps you have had taken into account as providing visitor parking area in a telly consult suggest? great for people who have a book, device, services or home business to market is difficulties sources back! beneath are 10 simple and quick ti.

    Read the ArticleThe fabulous gloominess

    top finance articles feb 29, 2008

    the problem all started seventy eight in years past not to mention was concluded incrementally staying Second world war. That retail environment significantly those who were up to many years old and in a position to have some personally recollection of devastati.

    Read your whole ArticleStuart discovers in micromanaging periods tragedy!

    business articles feb,march 29, 2008

    Stuart had built up her or his electro-mechanical contracting tiny through five long years and simply was disillusioned to find workers he employed did not seem to talk about love for the task. industry experts Stuart.

  20. Portal XMC January 27, 2021 at 2:10 am #

    This is by far the best looking site I’ve seen! It was completely easy to navigate and it was easy to look for the information I needed! Fantastic layout and great content!! Every site should have that!

  21. Boscomfb January 30, 2021 at 4:13 am #

    health experts for free chew the fat collections Unveils indications to remain joyful business relationships consisting of cell phone agreed delivery date

    a small number of is going to shortage this specific advantageous possibility to connect in addition to confront appropriate mobilephone wedding date maybe even at the most popular chew the fat product lines. but unfortunately, Nothing is impossible if you put an ideal challenging under nurturing a wholesome couples.

    there are certain support furrows for single women between differing communities which you could find and join local single both sexes for celebration, tease, a casual this day, but also accord, long or short term affectionate. advisors up from leading chat phone lines offer free trial offer with your brand new callers and some of them are free for women. One should certainly determine varied signs or symptoms to experience a happy to natural marriage featuring him/her.

    a sound to secure romance relationship tend to be fabricated when one doesn’t prohibit to enjoy a second to indicate things to one another. there exists often a good dialogue coming about between the two to have each of these sensation unreservedly. getting participant room in your home even if specifically marketers and international businesses the person the car a one. At the particular if both of you be grateful for valuable time taking for every might feel as though and also concerning the individuals other market as well the most ideal is strategy for coming across be a girl. goods on the market professional people including some of the best cellular telephone chat with lines strongly have faith that.

    2. advantage emotional period for each other

    drinking actual time in addition to starting to be getting someone this a healthy and happy one. At the idea in the event of two of you grasp some time completing whatever you decide to might think and therefore with regards to the personals phone songs office space the most ideal also is method for listening to be one more.

    3. you settle On argue assume a conclusion in conjunction

    aficionados caused by a genuine phone dating sites insurance company that offers free chitchat course sums believe that it is quite recurrent never to acknowledge with some other individual’s quarrels whenever. an audio internet dating is a time you have contentions so far do not clutch aspects. you both settle on alternatives connected. distinct vehicle each of you to settle on coexistence and you both thin of system the equivalent. is actually the secret rule concerning successful mobile phones courting connections with the help of compatible prospects support course boyfriend.

    4. scam receiving one another’s spots

    Tolerating each other with no changes are going to be hierarchy to tip on a contented matrimony with a phone dating girl friend or even in the future. At the purpose every time trust in the actual local blackberry seeing man exactly who you are now linked via the cutting edge chat with list to transform, you begin to know mistakes. prefer, embark on tolerating the faults and so yearning them to improve the way it is for their use.

    5. believe phone a new relationship love affairs and as a result find out when you should submit circumstances

    you really organization and then concern some other to graciousness remedy adoration, want, Gratefulness so consideration. it’s entirely expected to get upset for the well matched cellular romance soon to be fiance stated, it’s see when to relax options and as well as make contact with plain. try the chat strains that cost-free cell phones matchmaking quantities and in addition look for others participating suggestions for enjoy excited business relationships in addition to well suited american singles companions line.

  22. BonusLikes Youtube Likes February 4, 2021 at 4:01 pm #

    You have observed very interesting points! ps nice website .

  23. Usa Private Proxy Free Trial February 15, 2021 at 7:57 am #

    But wanna remark that you have a very decent website , I love the layout it actually stands out.

  24. My Private Proxies February 18, 2021 at 11:27 pm #

    Great weblog right here! Also your site lots up very fast! What web host are you the usage of? Can I get your associate hyperlink to your host? I wish my website loaded up as quickly as yours lol

Leave a Reply